Okay, so I have a huge exam coming up – finals week, basically. It’s worth a significant chunk of my grade in this class, and I’m really stressing about it. The exam is all multiple choice, and there’s no penalty for wrong answers. That is, you don’t lose any points for getting a question wrong; it’s the same as leaving it blank.
My question is, should I guess on the questions I’m not completely sure about? I’m generally a good student, but I always have a few questions where I can narrow it down to two possible answers, or even just one answer that seems more likely than the others, but I’m not 100% confident.
Normally, I’d just skip those, but with no penalty for wrong answers, it feels like I should guess. But then I worry that my gut feeling is wrong, and I’ll just decrease my chances of getting the right answer.
So, what’s the best strategy here? Should I always guess if there’s no penalty? Should I only guess if I can eliminate some answers? Or should I just leave them blank and hope for the best on the questions I do know? I’m looking for advice based on logic and probability, not just hunches. Also, is there any evidence for or against guessing in these situations? Thanks!
Answer
Whether or not you should guess on multiple-choice questions when you are unsure of the answer depends on the scoring system used. Let’s break down the scenarios and considerations:
1. Standard Multiple-Choice Scoring (Right/Wrong):
-
Scenario: You get a point for each correct answer. You get no points for incorrect answers.
-
Should you guess? Yes, almost always.
-
Reasoning: Since there is no penalty for a wrong answer, leaving a question blank guarantees you will get zero points for it. If you guess, even randomly, you have a chance of getting it correct. Even a small probability of a correct answer is better than a guaranteed zero.
- Example: If there are four options (A, B, C, D), and you randomly guess, you have a 25% chance of getting the question right. Over a large number of questions where you are unsure, these random guesses will statistically result in some correct answers, increasing your overall score.
-
2. Multiple-Choice with a Penalty for Wrong Answers (e.g., -1/4 point for each wrong answer):
-
Scenario: You get a point for each correct answer. You lose a fraction of a point for each incorrect answer. Leaving a question blank results in zero points. This is designed to discourage random guessing.
-
Should you guess? It depends on how you can narrow down the options.
-
If you have absolutely no idea: Leaving the question blank is usually the better strategy. The penalty for random guessing will likely outweigh the benefit of a lucky guess.
-
If you can eliminate one or more options: Guessing becomes more advantageous. The fewer options you have, the higher your probability of selecting the correct answer, and the more likely that your gains from correct guesses will outweigh the losses from incorrect guesses.
-
Example 1 (no options eliminated): Four options (A, B, C, D), and a penalty of -1/4 point for a wrong answer. If you guess randomly, your expected value is:
- 25% chance of getting it right (+1 point)
- 75% chance of getting it wrong (-0.25 points)
- Expected value = (0.25 1) + (0.75 -0.25) = 0.25 – 0.1875 = 0.0625. This is a positive value, suggesting that guessing will improve your score.
-
Example 2 (one option eliminated): Three options (A, B, C), and a penalty of -1/4 point for a wrong answer. If you guess randomly, your expected value is:
- 33.33% chance of getting it right (+1 point)
- 66.66% chance of getting it wrong (-0.25 points)
- Expected value = (0.3333 1) + (0.6666 -0.25) = 0.3333 – 0.16665 = 0.16665. Guessing will improve your score.
-
Example 3 (no options eliminated): Four options (A, B, C, D), and a penalty of -1/3 point for a wrong answer. If you guess randomly, your expected value is:
- 25% chance of getting it right (+1 point)
- 75% chance of getting it wrong (-0.3333 points)
- Expected value = (0.25 1) + (0.75 -0.3333) = 0.25 – 0.25 = 0.0. Leaving the question blank is better in this case.
-
Example 4 (one option eliminated): Three options (A, B, C), and a penalty of -1/3 point for a wrong answer. If you guess randomly, your expected value is:
- 33.33% chance of getting it right (+1 point)
- 66.66% chance of getting it wrong (-0.3333 points)
- Expected value = (0.3333 1) + (0.6666 -0.3333) = 0.3333 – 0.2222 = 0.1111. Guessing will improve your score.
-
Example 5 (two options eliminated): Two options (A, B), and a penalty of -1/4 point for a wrong answer. If you guess randomly, your expected value is:
- 50% chance of getting it right (+1 point)
- 50% chance of getting it wrong (-0.25 points)
- Expected value = (0.50 1) + (0.50 -0.25) = 0.50 – 0.125 = 0.375. Guessing will improve your score.
- General Rule for Penalties: A common guideline is to guess if you can eliminate at least one option, but to carefully calculate the expected value if you are unsure about the exact penalty.
-
3. Situations where Educated Guessing is Always Better:
-
Process of Elimination: Even if you don’t know the correct answer, carefully read each option and eliminate the ones you know are incorrect. This increases your chances of guessing correctly.
-
Test-Taking Strategies: Look for patterns. Are there any answers that seem to be consistently correct on other similar questions? Are some answers grammatically incorrect when placed in the context of the question?
- "All of the above" or "None of the above": Be very cautious with these. If you know that at least two of the options are correct when "All of the above" is an option, then "All of the above" is likely the answer. Similarly, if you know that at least one of the options is incorrect when "None of the above" is an option, then "None of the above" is unlikely to be the correct answer.
4. Important Considerations:
-
Time Management: Don’t spend too much time on any single question if you are truly stuck. Mark it and come back to it later if you have time. It’s better to answer all the questions you do know first.
-
Read Carefully: Make sure you understand what the question is asking before you even look at the options. Careless errors are easy to avoid.
- Trust Your Gut (Sometimes): If you have a strong feeling about an answer, even if you can’t articulate why, it might be worth considering. However, always try to back up your intuition with logic or process of elimination.
In summary, the decision to guess on multiple-choice questions should be based on a calculated strategy, considering the scoring system, your ability to eliminate options, and your overall test-taking approach.
