Okay, so I’m a middle school teacher – 7th grade Language Arts specifically. My students are terrible at giving and receiving feedback. It’s either gushing, unhelpful praise ("This is SO good!") or tearing each other down in the guise of "help" ("This makes no sense!").
We’re starting peer review on a creative writing project soon (short stories!), and I’m dreading it. Last year it was a complete disaster. Kids got their feelings hurt, no one actually improved their writing, and I basically ended up rewriting half the class’s stories myself.
I’ve tried explaining what constructive criticism IS – focusing on strengths and weaknesses, being specific, suggesting solutions – but it just doesn’t stick. They just don’t get it.
So, what are some practical strategies I can use to teach my students how to effectively give and receive constructive feedback? I need something more than just lectures; I need engaging activities and concrete examples. I’m thinking maybe some sort of structured worksheet or a game?
Also, how can I help them develop a thicker skin when it comes to receiving feedback, especially when it’s coming from their peers? They tend to take everything so personally. Any tips on fostering a more supportive and collaborative classroom environment would be greatly appreciated! And what do you think about having anonymous peer review? Would that help them be more honest, or just make things worse?
Answer
To effectively learn how to give and receive constructive feedback, students need a multifaceted approach that combines explicit instruction, modeling, practice, and reflection. Here’s a detailed breakdown of key strategies:
I. Establishing a Foundation of Understanding:
-
Defining Constructive Feedback: Begin by clearly defining what constructive feedback is and what it is not. Emphasize that it’s not simply praise or criticism, but specific, actionable information intended to improve performance or understanding. Contrast it with unhelpful feedback that is vague, personal, or judgmental. Provide concrete examples of both types.
- Highlighting the Purpose and Benefits: Discuss the purpose of feedback in learning and growth. Explain how it helps individuals:
- Identify strengths and areas for improvement.
- Understand expectations and standards.
- Develop skills and knowledge more effectively.
- Gain different perspectives.
- Promote a culture of continuous improvement.
- Develop self-awareness and metacognitive skills.
- Creating a Safe and Supportive Environment: Before diving into feedback exercises, establish classroom norms that promote psychological safety. This includes:
- Respectful communication: Active listening, avoiding interrupting, using polite language.
- Emphasizing growth mindset: Viewing feedback as an opportunity to learn and improve, rather than as a judgment of worth.
- Confidentiality: Maintaining the privacy of feedback shared within the classroom.
- Focus on behaviors and work, not on personal attributes.
II. Developing Skills for Giving Constructive Feedback:
- Providing Explicit Instruction on Effective Feedback Techniques: Teach students specific techniques for delivering feedback constructively. These include:
- The "sandwich" method (although this can be problematic if not done well): Start with a positive comment, follow with constructive criticism, and end with another positive comment or suggestion for improvement. However, emphasize that the positive aspects should be genuine and not simply filler.
- "I" statements: Frame feedback using "I" statements to express personal reactions and avoid accusatory language. For example, instead of saying "You were unprepared," say "I felt that the presentation could have been improved with more preparation."
- Specific and actionable feedback: Avoid vague comments like "Good job" or "Needs improvement." Instead, provide specific details about what was done well and what could be improved. Offer concrete suggestions for how to make those improvements. For example, instead of "The introduction was weak," say "The introduction could be strengthened by including a clear thesis statement that outlines the main arguments of the paper."
- Focus on observable behaviors and outcomes: Base feedback on what was actually seen or heard, rather than on assumptions or interpretations of intent. For instance, "The data in the graph was not clearly labeled," is better than "You didn’t put enough effort into the graph."
- Timeliness: Provide feedback as soon as reasonably possible after the performance or event, while the details are still fresh in everyone’s mind.
- Balance of positive and negative: While not always a perfect 50/50 split, ensure feedback includes both recognition of strengths and suggestions for improvement. This prevents the recipient from feeling solely criticized.
- Modeling Effective Feedback: Demonstrate good feedback practices by:
- Providing examples of constructive feedback on student work, either written or verbal, during class discussions.
- Engaging in role-playing scenarios where you model how to give feedback in different situations (e.g., peer review of writing, group project presentations).
- Think aloud: Verbalize your thought process as you analyze a piece of work and formulate constructive feedback.
- Providing Opportunities for Practice: Implement activities that allow students to practice giving feedback in a low-stakes environment:
- Peer review: Pair students to review each other’s work (e.g., essays, presentations, projects) using structured feedback forms.
- Group critiques: Have students provide feedback on group projects or performances, focusing on specific aspects outlined in a rubric.
- Role-playing: Assign students different roles (e.g., presenter, audience member) and have them practice giving and receiving feedback in simulated scenarios.
- Anonymous feedback: Use online tools or surveys to collect anonymous feedback on presentations or class discussions.
- Using Structured Feedback Forms/Rubrics: Provide students with structured forms or rubrics to guide their feedback. These forms should include specific criteria and prompts to encourage detailed and actionable feedback. For example:
- "What was one thing the presenter did particularly well?"
- "What is one specific suggestion you would make to improve the clarity of the presentation?"
- "How effectively did the group collaborate during the project? Provide specific examples."
- Providing Feedback on the Feedback: After students give feedback, provide them with feedback on the quality of their feedback. This helps them refine their skills and identify areas for improvement.
III. Developing Skills for Receiving Constructive Feedback:
- Active Listening and Clarification: Teach students how to actively listen to feedback without interrupting or becoming defensive. Encourage them to ask clarifying questions to ensure they understand the feedback fully. Examples:
- "Can you elaborate on what you mean by…?"
- "Could you provide a specific example of…?"
- "So, if I understand you correctly, you’re suggesting that…?"
- Controlling Emotional Reactions: Help students develop strategies for managing their emotional reactions to feedback, such as:
- Taking a deep breath and pausing before responding.
- Acknowledging the feedback without immediately agreeing or disagreeing.
- Focusing on the content of the feedback, rather than the tone or delivery.
- Separating the Message from the Messenger: Encourage students to focus on the validity of the feedback itself, rather than letting their feelings about the person giving the feedback influence their perception.
- Identifying Actionable Steps: Guide students to identify specific, actionable steps they can take based on the feedback they receive. Encourage them to create a plan for implementing the feedback and tracking their progress.
- Expressing Gratitude: Encourage students to express gratitude to the person giving the feedback, even if they don’t agree with it. This demonstrates respect and encourages others to continue providing feedback in the future.
- Self-Reflection: Facilitate opportunities for students to reflect on the feedback they receive and how it impacts their learning. Encourage them to journal about their reactions to the feedback, their plans for improvement, and their progress over time.
- Modeling Graceful Acceptance of Feedback: Model how to receive feedback gracefully by:
- Actively listening to feedback without interrupting.
- Asking clarifying questions to ensure understanding.
- Acknowledging the feedback and expressing gratitude.
- Reflecting on the feedback and identifying actionable steps for improvement.
IV. Ongoing Practice and Reinforcement:
- Regular Feedback Opportunities: Integrate regular opportunities for students to give and receive feedback throughout the course. This could include peer review, group critiques, self-assessments, and teacher feedback.
- Reflection and Revision: Encourage students to reflect on the feedback they receive and revise their work accordingly. This helps them internalize the feedback and develop a deeper understanding of the material.
- Metacognitive Activities: Incorporate activities that promote metacognitive awareness of feedback processes. For example, have students:
- Compare different pieces of feedback they received on the same assignment.
- Analyze their own feedback skills and identify areas for improvement.
- Discuss the challenges and benefits of giving and receiving feedback.
- Celebrating Growth: Recognize and celebrate students’ growth in their feedback skills. This could include providing positive feedback on their feedback, showcasing examples of effective feedback, and awarding points or badges for demonstrating good feedback practices.
By implementing these strategies, educators can equip students with the skills and mindset necessary to give and receive constructive feedback effectively, fostering a culture of continuous improvement and lifelong learning.
