How do I increase my chances of getting a return

Okay, so I bought this thing online. A "vintage" (supposedly) leather jacket from a seller on one of those resale apps. It arrived today, and honestly, it’s not what I expected. The listing photos were… well, they were clearly taken in really good lighting and probably filtered. In reality, the leather is way more cracked than it looked, there’s a weird smell I can’t quite place (mothballs maybe?), and I swear I saw a tiny hole near the collar that wasn’t mentioned.

I contacted the seller and said I wasn’t happy, but they’re being super resistant to accepting a return. They claim it’s "as described" and that any imperfections are just "character" from being vintage. Ugh.

So, what can I do? What evidence do I need to gather? Should I contact the resale app’s support team directly? How do I phrase my argument to maximize my chances of getting my money back? I really don’t want to be stuck with this smelly, damaged jacket! Any advice is appreciated!

Answer

To increase your chances of getting a return when purchasing items, whether online or in a physical store, consider the following strategies:

Before Purchase:

• Research the Seller/Store’s Return Policy: This is the most crucial step. Thoroughly read and understand the seller’s return policy before you buy anything. Look for these key details:

  • Return Window: How many days do you have to return the item?
  • Return Shipping Costs: Who pays for return shipping? Some sellers offer free return shipping, while others require you to pay.
  • Condition Requirements: What condition must the item be in to be eligible for a return (e.g., unused, original packaging, with tags attached)? Are there exceptions for defective items?
  • Refund Method: Will you receive a full refund, store credit, or an exchange?
  • Restocking Fees: Are there any restocking fees deducted from the refund?
  • Exclusions: Are there any items that are not eligible for return (e.g., final sale items, personalized items, hygiene products)?
  • Proof of Purchase: What proof of purchase is required (e.g., receipt, order confirmation email)?

• Read Product Reviews: Check product reviews from other customers to identify potential issues with the item, such as sizing problems, defects, or discrepancies between the product description and reality. This can help you make a more informed purchasing decision and avoid needing to return the item in the first place.

• Ask Questions Before Buying: If you have any doubts or uncertainties about the product, don’t hesitate to contact the seller or store and ask questions. Clarify any ambiguities in the product description or return policy. Keep a record of your communication.

• Take Photos/Videos of New Purchases: Upon receiving your item, especially for electronics or fragile items, take photos or videos of the unboxing process. This can serve as evidence if the item arrives damaged or defective.

• Consider Payment Methods with Return Protection: Some credit cards and payment platforms (like PayPal) offer return protection benefits. If the seller refuses a return that meets their criteria, you may be able to file a claim with your credit card company or payment platform to get a refund. Review the terms and conditions of the return protection program before making a purchase.

• Buy from Reputable Sellers/Stores: Opt for established and reputable sellers or stores with a history of good customer service. Check their ratings and reviews online.

During the Return Process:

• Act Quickly: Initiate the return process as soon as you decide you want to return the item, and well within the return window specified in the return policy.

• Follow the Seller’s Instructions: Carefully follow the seller’s instructions for initiating the return. This may involve filling out a return form, contacting customer service, or generating a return shipping label.

• Keep Detailed Records: Keep records of all communication with the seller, including emails, chat logs, and phone calls. Save copies of return forms, shipping labels, and tracking information.

• Package the Item Carefully: Repackage the item securely in its original packaging (if possible). If the original packaging is not available, use appropriate packing materials to protect the item from damage during shipping.

• Obtain Tracking Information: When shipping the item back to the seller, obtain a tracking number and keep it in a safe place. This will allow you to track the progress of the return and confirm that the seller has received the item.

• Communicate Professionally and Respectfully: Maintain a professional and respectful tone in all communication with the seller. Clearly explain the reason for the return and provide any necessary documentation.

• Escalate if Necessary: If the seller is unresponsive or refuses to honor the return policy, escalate the issue. You can try contacting customer service again, filing a complaint with the Better Business Bureau, or contacting your credit card company or payment platform to dispute the charge.

Important Considerations:

• "Final Sale" Items: Be aware that items marked as "final sale" are typically not eligible for return.
• Digital Products and Services: Return policies for digital products and services (e.g., software downloads, streaming subscriptions) are often more restrictive than those for physical goods.
• Hygiene Products: For hygiene reasons, certain items like underwear, swimwear, and personal care products are often not returnable if they have been opened or used.
• Customized or Personalized Items: Customized or personalized items are typically not returnable unless they are defective or damaged.

By following these guidelines, you can significantly increase your chances of getting a return when needed.

Written by

Studentanswers Editorial Team

University Admissions, GPA, SAT/ACT, Teacher Careers, Student Finance Expertise: Education Content Specialist & Research Writer 19+ years of experience

I'm Mustafa Bulut, an education researcher and content specialist with over a decade of experience helping students navigate the complexities of academic life — from decoding GPA scales to understanding what top universities actually look for in applicants. My work focuses on making higher education accessible and understandable. I've spent years researching university admissions processes, standardized testing systems (SAT, ACT, TOEFL), and the real-world career paths that follow graduation. Whether you're a high school junior trying to figure out if your GPA is competitive for Ivy League schools, or an adult learner weighing the cost of going back to school, I write with you in mind. I cover five core areas on StudentAnswers: university admissions and GPA benchmarks, SAT and ACT test preparation strategies, teacher career outlooks and education job markets, global literacy trends and education access, and student finance including loans, scholarships, and hidden costs of higher education. Before launching StudentAnswers, I worked extensively with education data — analyzing acceptance rates, salary statistics for education professionals, and literacy reports from UNESCO and national education departments. I believe that good education content should give readers a clear answer, not just more questions. Every article I publish goes through a research and editorial review process. I cite primary sources wherever possible — official university data, government labor statistics, and peer-reviewed education research — because students deserve accurate information when making decisions that shape their futures.

✓ Reviewed by: Studentanswers Editorial Team ✓ Fact-checked: 29 October 2025

All Articles