Okay, so I’m applying to colleges this fall. I took the ACT and the SAT, and honestly, my scores weren’t great. They’re definitely below average for the schools I’m really hoping to get into – places like State University, City College, and maybe even reach schools like Prestige U. I’m talking maybe a composite ACT score of around a 25 and an SAT around 1100.
The question is, should I even bother submitting them? A lot of schools are test-optional now, and I’m wondering if it would actually hurt my chances more than help if they see these scores. I have a pretty good GPA (around a 3.8), and I think my essays are strong. I also have some solid extracurriculars, especially with the debate club and volunteering at the animal shelter.
Basically, I’m trying to figure out if my application is stronger without the scores, highlighting my other achievements. Or, do the colleges still want to see scores, even if they’re not amazing? Are they looking for context around the scores, or will they just see them and immediately think I’m not qualified? What factors should I be considering to make this decision? Is there a general rule of thumb?
Answer
Whether or not you should submit your test scores when they are below average depends heavily on the specific colleges you are applying to and their testing policies. Here’s a detailed breakdown to help you make an informed decision:
1. Understand the College’s Testing Policy:
-
Test-Optional: This means the college does not require standardized test scores (SAT or ACT) for admission. Applying without scores will not negatively impact your application. Many colleges have adopted this policy, especially since the pandemic. If a college is test-optional and your scores are below their average, it is generally advisable NOT to submit them. Your application will be evaluated based on other factors.
-
Test-Blind: These colleges do not consider standardized test scores at all, even if you submit them. They are removed from your application before review. Submitting scores to a test-blind college is pointless.
-
Test-Required: Some colleges still require standardized test scores. These are becoming rarer, but it’s crucial to check. If a college is test-required, you must submit scores to be considered for admission. However, even in this scenario, there are nuances to consider (see the "Submitting Scores Even if Below Average" section below).
- Test-Flexible: These colleges may allow you to submit other types of scores in lieu of the SAT/ACT, such as AP exams or IB scores. Understand exactly what "flexible" means at each institution.
2. Define "Below Average":
-
College Score Ranges: Colleges typically publish the middle 50% range (25th to 75th percentile) of accepted students’ SAT/ACT scores. Find this information on the college’s website (usually under "Admissions" or "First-Year Profile"). This range represents the scores of the majority of admitted students.
- Compare Your Scores: Compare your scores to the published range. If your score falls below the 25th percentile, it’s generally considered below average for that particular college. If it’s within the range, even near the lower end, it may still be beneficial to submit (more on this later).
3. Evaluate Your Application Holistically:
-
Strength of Other Application Components: If your scores are below average, a strong application in other areas becomes even more critical. Consider the following:
-
GPA and Course Rigor: A high GPA in challenging courses (e.g., AP, IB, dual enrollment) can demonstrate academic ability and compensate for lower test scores. A transcript that showcases academic growth is also advantageous.
-
Essays: Compelling essays that reveal your personality, critical thinking skills, writing ability, and unique experiences can significantly strengthen your application.
-
Letters of Recommendation: Glowing letters of recommendation from teachers and counselors who know you well can highlight your strengths, work ethic, and potential.
-
Extracurricular Activities: Meaningful involvement in extracurricular activities that demonstrate leadership, passion, commitment, and impact can showcase your well-roundedness.
- Unique Talents and Experiences: Exceptional talents (e.g., artistic, musical, athletic) or unique life experiences can set you apart from other applicants.
-
4. Submitting Scores Even if Below Average:
There are some situations where submitting scores, even if below the average range, might be beneficial:
-
Demonstrating Improvement: If you took the SAT/ACT multiple times and your scores show significant improvement, submitting all scores might demonstrate your dedication and ability to learn and grow. This is especially true if the most recent score is closer to the college’s range.
-
Specific Program Requirements: Some specific programs within a university (e.g., engineering, nursing) may have different testing requirements or expectations than the university as a whole. Research the specific program requirements.
-
Overcoming Disadvantages: If you faced significant disadvantages during your education (e.g., attending an under-resourced school, experiencing personal hardship), submitting scores, even if below average, can provide context for your academic performance. Use the "Additional Information" section of the application to explain these circumstances.
- Superscoring: Some colleges "superscore," meaning they take your highest section scores across multiple test dates to create a new composite score. If a college superscores and your individual section scores are strong in different areas across multiple tests, submitting all your scores might be advantageous. Check the college’s superscoring policy.
5. Factors to Consider When Deciding:
- Your Score Relative to the 25th Percentile: How far below the 25th percentile is your score? A score just below the 25th percentile might be less detrimental than a score significantly below.
- Overall Strength of Your Application: How strong are your other application components? If your GPA, essays, and extracurriculars are exceptional, you might be able to overcome lower test scores.
- Fit with the College: Does your application, as a whole, demonstrate a good fit with the college’s values, mission, and academic programs?
- Consult with Your Counselor: Your high school counselor can provide personalized advice based on your academic record, test scores, and college list.
In Summary:
- Test-Optional/Test-Blind: Generally, do not submit below-average scores.
- Test-Required: You must submit scores. Focus on strengthening other application components and providing context if necessary.
- Other Cases: Carefully weigh the factors discussed above. Err on the side of not submitting scores if they are significantly below average and your application is strong in other areas.
The most important thing is to make an informed decision based on the specific policies of the colleges you are applying to and a realistic assessment of your application’s strengths and weaknesses.
